SHARE Share Button Share Button SHARE

Lawyer sees ‘road map’ for Vermont tuition fight

By ALEX HANSON

Valley News Staff Writer

The Vermont Supreme Court has dismissed a lawsuit brought by three families who argued that the state should pay for all students to attend the school of their choice, public or private.

The court’s March 17 decision in Vitale v. Vermont affirms a ruling from state Superior Court in Orleans County. Both courts effectively declined to hear the case on the ground that the plaintiffs were not asking for something the court could provide.

The Vermont Constitution and subsequent state law requires the maintenance of public schools, but allows districts that can’t or don’t wish to maintain a school for some or all grades to pay tuition to a public school in another district or an approved private school.

The families who filed suit, one of them from Chelsea, argued that the state law permitting some students access to tuition is unfair on its face, meaning that there is no circumstance under which the law could be valid. That’s a high bar to clear, and the court’s decision, written by Harold “Duke” Eaton Jr., and unanimously approved by the five justices, invites another attempt, which one of the lawyers for the plaintiffs sees as a victory.

“Our conclusion in this case does not end the evolution of the debate over how the state should educate Vermont children,” the decision says. “It also does not foreclose the possibility that a plaintiff could bring a challenge that satisfies the legal standards stated in this opinion.”

“Of course, we’re somewhat disap-

‘ROAD MAP’ A3

SHARE Share Button Share Button SHARE